Structured Thinking Session Questions How to run this Pick three or four questions, not thirty A session that works through every question stops being a conversation Choose the ones that fit where the group actually is Ask the question, then wait The useful answer usually arrives after the uncomfortable pause Resist filling the silence with a reframe Capture answers as branches, not minutes One branch per contribution, in the contributor's own words Tidy later, in Understand, not while people are still talking Name whose view is absent before you close Golden Rule 2: no single view is the whole picture 01 Capture What do we know? Who do we serve? How would they define our purpose? What is the deeper purpose that makes this worthy of our best efforts? What inhibitors and constraints do we face in trying to achieve it? What opportunities do we see that could help us achieve it? What else might others do to improve the situation we face? What do we know, and what are we only assuming? [added] What do we not know yet? [added] 02 Understand What does it mean? What is emerging here, and what new connections could be made? What has surprised you in what you have heard? What has challenged you in what you have heard? What is missing from the picture so far? What dilemmas do we face in trying to achieve our purpose? What is the next level of thinking we all need to do? If there is one thing not yet mentioned that could take us deeper, what would it be? What appears to be cause, and what appears to be symptom? [added] Where does what we say differ from what we do? [added] 03 Decide What should we do? What is possible, and who cares? What would it take to create beneficial change? If success were guaranteed, what bold steps might we choose to take? Handle with care This question suspends uncertainty on purpose, to get past self-censoring Do not let the answers leave the room still wearing that assumption Golden Rule 7: say what you do not know What alternatives genuinely exist, beyond the first plausible answer? [added] Is this a contradiction to resolve, or a tension to manage? [added] What legitimate objective could this choice damage? [added] 04 Commit What are we agreeing to? What should be our top priority? What needs to happen for you to feel fully engaged on this? How can we support each other in the next phase? What contribution can each of us make? What challenges might crop up, and how might we meet them? Who owns the outcome, and do they have the authority, resources and information to deliver it? [added] What are we stopping, delaying or refusing to make room for this? [added] Where does the owner have freedom to judge the method? [added] 05 Define Success How will we know? Compared with what? What is true today? [added] If we cannot describe the before situation, we are not ready to define improvement What will be different, described plainly enough to recognise? [added] What evidence, measured or observed, will show it? [added] Who agrees this is the success we are aiming for, by name? [added] What seed might we plant today that would make the most difference to our future? Facilitator questions, outside the five stages These are about the session, not about the subject Opening What would make this session worth the time we are all giving it? Closing What has been your biggest insight from this session? What conversation begun today could create new possibilities later? Why they sit outside They ask about the conversation rather than about the work Forcing them into a stage inflates that stage and hides what the shape is telling you Not everything has to fit the five stages merely because there are five stages Where these questions come from The original set is 23 questions in three clusters To focus collective attention, 7 To connect ideas and find deeper insights, 7 To create forward movement, 9 The set comes from the powerful questions tradition 15 questions were added from the Structured Thinking Handbook Marked [added] throughout so the original set stays recognisable They fill gaps the mapping exposed, and are not evenly spread 2 of the original 23 sit in the facilitator group rather than under a stage What the shape of this map showed us Of the 21 source questions that map to a stage: Capture 6, Understand 7, Decide 3, Commit 4, Define Success 1 Decide and Define Success arrived as thin branches The set was built to open a conversation, not to close one See Reading the Shape in the Structured Thinking Handbook